When designing or upgrading large-diameter pipeline systems, valve selection has a direct impact on cost, operability, reliability, and long-term maintenance. Two of the most commonly considered options are butterfly valves and gate valves.

Although both serve isolation purposes, they behave very differently—especially as pipeline sizes increase. This article breaks down how each valve works, where each excels, and which one makes more sense for large pipelines such as water transmission lines, cooling water systems, and utility networks.

1. Basic Working Principles

Butterfly Valve

A butterfly valve uses a rotating disc mounted on a central shaft.

• Turning the actuator 90° rotates the disc from fully open to fully closed
• The disc remains inside the flow path even when fully open

Gate Valve

A gate valve uses a linear-moving gate that lifts completely out of the flow path.

• The gate moves up and down via a rising or non-rising stem
• When fully open, the valve provides an unobstructed bore

2. Size, Weight, and Space Requirements

Butterfly Valves

✔ Compact face-to-face dimension
✔ Much lighter weight
✔ Easier to transport and install in DN600+ pipelines

Gate Valves

✖ Very heavy in large diameters
✖ Require more vertical clearance
✖ Installation often needs lifting equipment and reinforced supports

Winner for large pipelines: Butterfly valve

3. Cost Considerations (Especially DN500 and Above)

As pipeline diameter increases, cost differences between butterfly valves and gate valves become more pronounced, especially in large-scale infrastructure projects.

Butterfly Valves – Cost Advantages

• Require significantly less raw material, especially in large diameters
• More compact design reduces casting and machining costs
• Lower valve weight results in cheaper transportation and installation
• Shorter face-to-face dimension reduces civil and piping support costs
• Lower actuator cost due to quarter-turn operation
• Overall lower lifecycle cost (purchase + installation + maintenance)

Gate Valves – Higher Cost Drivers

• Large body and gate require much more metal in DN500+ sizes
• Complex structure increases manufacturing and machining costs
• Heavy weight leads to higher transport, lifting, and installation expenses
• Often require larger actuators or gearboxes, increasing total package cost
• Maintenance and part replacement are more labor-intensive and expensive

Practical takeaway:
For DN600–DN2000 pipelines, a gate valve can cost 2–4 times more than a butterfly valve, making butterfly valves the preferred choice for budget-sensitive large pipeline projects.

4. Flow Characteristics & Pressure Loss

Gate Valves

✔ Full bore when open
✔ Minimal pressure drop
✔ Ideal where head loss must be minimized

Butterfly Valves

✖ Disc causes some flow obstruction
✖ Higher pressure drop than gate valves
✔ Acceptable for most water and utility systems

Winner for minimal pressure loss: Gate valve

‍

5. Operation Speed & Automation

Butterfly Valves

✔ Quarter-turn operation
✔ Fast opening and closing
✔ Excellent for electric or pneumatic actuators

Gate Valves

✖ Multiple turns required
✖ Slower operation
✖ Less ideal for frequent cycling

Winner for automation and control: Butterfly valve

6. Maintenance & Reliability

Butterfly Valves

✔ Fewer moving parts
✔ Easier seal replacement
✔ Lower maintenance cost

Gate Valves

✖ Stem and gate wear over time
✖ Sealing surfaces prone to damage
✖ Maintenance is more labor-intensive

Winner for ease of maintenance: Butterfly valve

7. Typical Applications in Large Pipelines

Butterfly Valves Are Commonly Used In:

• Municipal water transmission
• Cooling water systems
• Fire protection mains
• Large HVAC and utility pipelines

Gate Valves Are Still Preferred In:

• Systems requiring full bore flow
• Applications with infrequent operation
• Locations where pressure loss is critical

Final Recommendation

Choose a Butterfly Valve if:

• Pipe size is large (DN500+)
• Space and weight matter
• Budget is a concern
• Automation or frequent operation is required

Choose a Gate Valve if:

• Full bore flow is mandatory
• Pressure loss must be minimized
• Operation frequency is very low

Bottom Line

For most large-diameter pipeline projects, butterfly valves are the practical, economical, and modern choice. Gate valves still have their place—but in large pipelines, they are increasingly reserved for specific technical requirements rather than default selection.

‍

‍

‍